Everton 1 Arsenal 0
IT’S a disappointing result but not one that tells us much we didn’t already know. Any side would struggle with their top three attackers out and their first choice wingers short on form and fitness.
Sure, the likes of Cesc, Rosicky and Hleb could and should contribute a few more. But look at United and for Ronaldo and Rooney you see Henry and Van Persie, for Saha’s eight you see Adebayor’s six and for Solskjaer’s six you see Gilberto’s eight. Giggs and Scholes have scored more than Rosicky and Hleb, but even they only have four and five respectively.
Of course, Cesc has not a single league goal. But then that’s just one less than Carrick. It’s similar at Chelsea - where without Lampard and Drogba, they would struggle massively. The point is that with Henry, RVP and Adebayor all out and Gilberto no longer in the midfield, we looked seriously blunted.
This, like the Villa game, was one that could have gone either way, which is why we beat Villa and lost to Everton.
We are injury (and in Adebayor’s case suspension) hit. Yet still, we started yesterday with six of what you would call our starting 11. The problem was that two of those were out of position, and so was Justin Hoyte. Quite feasibly, we could have started with Gallas and Toure at centre-back and Gilberto and Cesc in front of them, with Hoyte at right-back.
Ok, so left-back might have been a problem, but given our current lack of confidence, a bit of stability would hardly go amiss. I may be wrong but to me it seems to point towards Arsene plumping for a Gilberto-Gallas partnership next year.
Maybe he has decided that while Cesc and Gilberto both merit a place in the side, they are not a title winning midfield.
Playa ratings:
Jens: Was not to blame directly for the goal but it always worries me when I see him getting involved at a corner. You just sense all the fuss achieves is a loss of concentration among both him and his defenders. Did well otherwise. 6.5
Hoyte: One dodgy bit of defending where he completely lost his man but otherwise I thought he was as good as any of our defenders. Is not the greatest player in the world, but has improved massively. 6.5
Gallas: I think he can do a lot better. Sure, fighting for third or fourth is not as fun as challenging for the title. But it is for players like him to change that. At the moment it looks like he is playing from memory. 5.5
Gilberto: Did ok, though seemed to have his silly hat on at times where he makes stupid decisions. I’m happy to give him time to get used to life at the back. 6
Toure: Did ok defensively, though looked less comfortable than at centre-back. Also didn’t really get forward as much as you would hope from Toure at right-back. 6
Diaby: Quiet and loose in the first half, much better after the break. His touch can improve, but he did ok. 6.5
Cesc: Really the only player in today’s side whose performance would have merited a place in the United or Chelsea teams. Drove us forward, got in three good shots that were on target and was generally our best player. 7
Ljungberg: Is not playing that badly but the problem is that because of his age, the weaknesses he has are only going to become more obvious as time passes. And as it is, his best is barely good enough. 6.5
Rosicky: Very quiet - he looked unfit. Has shown promise this season but he will know he can be more effective. 6
Baptista: Truly anonymous for an hour and on the odd occasion he did touch the ball, he lost it. Also missed a great headed opportunity on the stroke of half time. Then got into the game more and showed what he can do without making the difference. God knows whether we should keep him: he has looked shocking at times and yet it is hard to believe he could genuinely be that shocking. 5.5
Aliadiere: Missed one good chance, which contrary to what Andy Gray claimed, did appear to skip up. In a struggling side, Aliadiere has hardly set the world on fire when given his chance. But equally, his general play has not been so bad. 6
Subs:
Hleb: Little impact. 5.5
Theo: Struggled to make his mark. 5.5
Denilson: No time.